Unfortunately, the gifting rules as they currently exist only allow for the gifting of mundane items or items that previously belonged to the receiving character. Items that would give another character a special ability or abilities would fall under the same rulings as directly wishing to give another character those abilities, and thus be rejected.
As this wish would be granted by Myrta, there is no humiliating or detrimental side-effect for failure; the wish simply fails. Your shard total remains unchanged.
If someone buys an item for themself and gives it to another later, would they get in trouble for it? How does gifting others with special effects work?
Is this only a magical item ruling or nonmagical too? If someone say got a bag of holding and gave it to someone else to borrow/hold would they get in trouble or?
We're fine with mundane gifts! In general, any intent to permanently give special abilities and powers to another character would be where we'd make the distinction.
Borrowing/temporarily using is fine.
Also any object that is canonically shared by multiple characters would also be acceptable to gift regardless of powers.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
DENIED
As this wish would be granted by Myrta, there is no humiliating or detrimental side-effect for failure; the wish simply fails. Your shard total remains unchanged.
no subject
If someone buys an item for themself and gives it to another later, would they get in trouble for it? How does gifting others with special effects work?
Is this only a magical item ruling or nonmagical too? If someone say got a bag of holding and gave it to someone else to borrow/hold would they get in trouble or?
no subject
Borrowing/temporarily using is fine.
Also any object that is canonically shared by multiple characters would also be acceptable to gift regardless of powers.